Montgomery Council Slams Pepco Performance
Pepco says there have been fewer outages and shorter recovery times.
The lack of reliable electric power has become the No.1 quality-of-life issue in the county and the June 29 storm and resulting outages are proof that Pepco hasn’t been doing its job, according to Montgomery County Council President Roger Berliner (D-Dist. 1) in a Montgomery County Council debriefing on Pepco’s response to the storm.
But the utility is making strides with fewer outages and shorter recovery times since 2010, said Pepco Region President Thomas Graham. Pepco has been implementing a five-year reliability plan, which includes managing trees near wires, upgrading feeders and burying some power lines.
The June 29 storm was unpredicted and no utility company with overhead wires could have recovered quickly, Graham said. There were more than 200 wires down, 242 poles replaced and 214 transformers replaced, according to Pepco statistics.
Still, both state and county legislators were not convinced.
“You’ve been happy to send checks to shareholders and let the infrastructure rot,” Councilman Mark Elrich (D-At Large) said of Pepco.
A large fine should be imposed on Pepco and the money should be used to train retired utility workers to work on Pepco’s infrastructure and equipment, State Sen. Brian Frosh (D-Dist. 18) said.
"We need people right here that can do this work so we don’t have to wait for them to be brought in," Frosh said.
Councilman Hans Reimer (D-At Large) took issue with Pepco’s performance in comparison to other utility companies.
“There are trees and bad weather in many jurisdictions and those people have power,” Reimer said. “The problem is Pepco’s set of values. It values its shareholders and its executives."
Reimer noted that Pepco CEO Joseph Rigby was not at the meeting to face the criticism.
Congressman Chris Van Hollen (D-Dist. 8) was not at the meeting, but issued a report that also studied how Pepco performed comparatively.
Although Dominion had more than double the number of outages as Pepco at the start of the restoration effort on the evening of June 29, the number of Pepco and Dominion customers without power was almost equal by July 2, according to the report.
Van Hollen also called for the Maryland Public Service Commission to reject Pepco’s pending request for a 4 percent rate increase.
The next step is hearing from residents. There will be eight public hearings across the state, including one in Montgomery County on Aug. 7.
Joe Thomas
5:04 pm on Thursday, July 19, 2012
These politicians make me sick. Its politically safe to jump on Pepco right now with both feet because no one likes to have their power out.
Look at other cities. When they have natural disasters (yes the storm of June 29th was a natural disaster) they have power outages that last longer than ours.
In 1992 friend who live in Florida had no power for five weeks after Andrew.
In 1998 people in eastern Canada had no power for six weeks after a severe ice storm.
Its going to happen. Deal with it.
Steve O
8:48 pm on Thursday, July 19, 2012
Those are just anecdotes. It’s politcally safe to pile on Pepco because their reliability sucks. Even removing storms from the equation Pepco’s customers experience 70% more outages than similar utilities.
Add to that the fact that in the last several major outages they have been slower to respond and slower to restore power than bordering utilities and people have a right to be angry.
People are also angry that they’d cut back maintenance and reliability work at the same time they increased executive bonuses which appears to be related.
You’re comparing a direct hit by category 5 hurricane and a 6 day long record ice storm to a summer storm that topped out at 80mph. Just because at some point someplace may have had a worse outage means nothing. Parts of Haiti went months without power after the earthquake, so hey, at least we’re doing better than poorest nation in the hemisphere!
Pam Coblyn
7:04 am on Friday, July 20, 2012
I'm curious, Joe Thomas. Please tell me why you think I should "deal" with repeated outages when the sun is shining and there is no wind? When there is a light rain? When there is a 10 mph breeze?
I think Pepco needs to "deal" with antiquated and unreliable equipment!
Let me remind you that our elected politicians are jumping on Pepco with both feet precisely because they are listening to their constituents and it is the will of the people.
Michael
9:18 am on Friday, July 20, 2012
Montgomery County is responsible by law for maintaining trees on right aways controlled by Montgomery County. There are about 450,000 trees that need to be maintained. The County Council and the Executive have stripped the Tree Department of all funds to maintain and prune the trees they are responsible for. The County Council and Executive do not tell the public the whole truth. They have totally failed to do their part in tree maintainance . This ought to be investigated by an independent council.
ED
9:40 am on Friday, July 20, 2012
It is my understanding that Montgomery County is responsible for pruning trees in the right-of-way, but are not allowed to prune trees that are around power lines - that responsibility falls on Pepco.
B Allen
9:58 am on Friday, July 20, 2012
All that money is going to pay for the illegal aliens that they bring here and sign up to vote in the elections. Ask your council member rep how much is going for that, they won't tell you, but you can get the numbers elsewhere. The amount would be well spent comng back to ALL the residents of MoCo and MD, even the dumb ones who vote for the people "watching the henhouse" http://www.fairus.org/site/DocServer/md_costsw.pdf?docID=4001
B Allen
10:52 am on Friday, July 20, 2012
@Frank, it is going well and I will make sure you and others like you WILL NOT be able to partake AND SHARE in any of my wealth. haha I will be involved in an $11B plus market... which I would be happy with just 1% of it. mmmmmmm maybe I should start looking at a place in Barbados or the Bahamas, maybe even costa rico. Whie you people just live off the governemtn and each other.
B Allen
9:43 am on Friday, July 20, 2012
What needs to be done is the people on the county council, the state legislators up to the gov, They should keep their paws off PEPCO affairs, quit making them pay fines, stop the unconstitutional so called "cap and trade" $15M/yr tax burder that was passed by the MC council. All of this adds to the cost for the utility, most in taxes. While doing that, turn the fines around and charge all of those people who cry because a tree is being trimmed or cut down on or near their property. I feel the people whose trees bring down wires and destroy equipment because of their childish actions should pay for the damage. PEPCO does not have antiquated equipment, they are updating it all the time. Berhliner and other councilmembers want to take over the utility, just think where you will be if that happened...you will be in the dark more so than you are now, BTW, your leader NOBAMA said there will be rolling blackouts, because his admin and the DOE have shut down power producing plants. Again all because gvmt steps in and regulates, increases the number of fines and burdens businesses http://www.instituteforenergyresearch.org/epa-powerplant-closures/
B Allen
10:53 am on Friday, July 20, 2012
Frank, the problem is when you have the government know nothings "stirring the pot" there will always be a problem. You should know that by now, it happens WAY too much, especially here in MD.
B Allen
10:12 am on Friday, July 20, 2012
Councilman Hans Reimer should just sit down and shut up. He is nothing more than a community activist that was put there to agitate, rub resentments, fan hostilities, and search out controversy. He is taking his MO right out of alinskys "rules for radicals" and I am sure he is a card carrying member of the SPUSA... it is because of people like him and others in the MD government this republic is going down the tubes just like CA. Most of the village ididots on the council are from CA.
Pam Coblyn
10:15 am on Friday, July 20, 2012
Please answer me this: If, as you assert "PEPCO does not have antiquated equipment", why does my entire neighborhood experience repeated outages that are not the result of tree damage. As I stated, our power went out 3X since the June 29 storm and there were no trees involved. Before you make wild assertions about equipment, check the facts.
B Allen
10:29 am on Friday, July 20, 2012
Your power can go out in your neighborhood due to a tree taking out lines in other areas. The power grid is not concentrated in one area after another it is ALL integrated. Lines can go down 2 miles away from you and blow out the transformers that control an entire area. Sure the utility companies need to keep upgrading their equipment but when they are fined all the time, that takes money away from maintenance and increases consumer costs. Just like the unconstitutional "cap and trade that the idiot behrliner had passed through the MOCO council against Mirant. He took plans out of henry waxmans playbook (because he worked for waxman) and drove up the costs to the consumers, when his office told me that would not happen, surprise, surprise. Like I said, these dems in MD have no clue how a busines is run. 3 more yrs and I will be taking my tax dollars away from MD also.
B Allen
10:45 am on Friday, July 20, 2012
Also, read the article I posted, the NObama admin and the EPA closed more plants, which in turn reduces the amount of power being made. NObama is living up to at least one of his promises, he said there will be rolling blackouts and power outages...call him and thank him, I am sure you voted for him and he would be so glad to hear that you still support his socialist views and put the blame elsewhere, as a good little "party member" does.
Joe Thomas
2:20 pm on Friday, July 20, 2012
A frequent cause of power outages when storms are not involved are cars striking poles. I was in MVA last week and all of the lights went out. An alert employee went outside and saw that a car and cut a power pole in half on Clopper Rd. It affected a large area on the west side of Gaithersburg. This happens more than you realize.
Michael Shapiro
10:15 am on Friday, July 20, 2012
As with many things, this is a complicated problem, with a simple, wrong answer, to paraphrase H.L. Mencken.
1. PEPCO is responsible, to a great degree. What many forget is that its not a short term problem. For many decades, PEPCO has not done proper ongoing maintenance and trimming of the trees that have the potential to fall on power lines.
2. The County has probably neglected to keep the trees, that were not necessarily in PEPCO's purview, properly maintained. And this could easily have meant cutting down some of the trees that were on the downside of their lifespan.
3. How many of us, as homeowners, properly maintained those trees that are on our property? How many would have allowed PEPCO to come onto our property to trim, were it not an emergency?
4. See 1,2,3. Tree maintenance is expensive, whether you are a homeowner, PEPCO, or a county government. Differed maintenance is the bane of many people, organizations, companies, and governments. This is simply an example that has come back to bite us all in the hindquarters. Whether it is because you can't afford it (homeowner), don't want to raise taxes (governments), or feel the need to continue to have a better looking bottom line (PEPCO, and other companies) putting off such items is a bad idea.
5. Putting out fudged projections is a common tactic to avoid spending, now. The billions that putting wires underground would cost should be adjusted by income lost, extra crews brought in, etc.
B Allen
10:39 am on Friday, July 20, 2012
Michael, I know people that work for pepco and they get hammered by homeowners all the time about going on to their property to trim trees. One homeowner in bethesda held up a crew for well over an hour by not letting them on to their property with the equipment to trim trees all because they did not want "tire track" on their lawn. With people like that, others suffer and blame PEPCO. They should be blaming their neighbors. But then again, that isthe leftist way to blame the MEAN "profit making" corporation...just as the alinsky loving MOCo council is doing. THEY want to take it over, then where do you think you will be, I know, more in the dark. If I was PEPCO, I would tell those that are complaining so much to go and find another power company and turn their electric off...see how they would like that. Act like children, be treated like children. My power was out, we dealt with it. My 80plus yo in laws power was out, we worked together and took care of business. My 80yo plus inlaws NEVER complained once. It is the community activists that are causing a stir, now that is the problem.
Pam Coblyn
10:47 am on Friday, July 20, 2012
Repairmen sent to our neighborhood have described our transformers and lines as "old, antiquated and falling apart". Not all outages have trees as their root problem (excuse the pun). I am outraged that an endemic equipment problem is being swept aside by those who claim it is always the trees. Sometimes it is—in fact, the SAME TREE that caused the 2010 power outage caused the Derecho outage. Neighbors pleaded with trimmers to take the whole thing down. It had visibly dead large limbs and one of these inevitably fell on June 29. We have not had the maintenance we deserve—neither on the many diseased trees that neighbors want taken down nor for the rusty transformers that continually fail.
CitizenK
10:55 am on Friday, July 20, 2012
Much of the tree trimming done by PEPCO's contractors creates some of the tree-related issues. If you prune a tree in such a way that it is left in a weakened state, it will be more likely to fall in a storm. I do not think that homeowners would have as many problems with allowing PEPCO contractors access IF proper pruning techniques were used. It is better to remove a tree than butcher the tree and then let it fall during a storm.
Esther D
11:10 am on Friday, July 20, 2012
Pepco needs to step up and stop pointing fingers at others in their contracts. they have a repsonsibilty too! THIS IS WHERE PEPCO FAILED! For example elderly couple in Bethesda senior living out of power. The power outage started minutes into the storm. The building had a generator that poured out toxic fumes so they were unable to open the window. The power outage lasted for 7 days ( Friday morning). During this time the generator only provided partial electricity for the entire building NO AC! (did I mention it was an seniors building). The hallway at times was cooler than the apartment regardless of a single fan in the apartment it was unbearable. The elevators were out of commission until an elderly gentleman in a wheelchair who just came back from a hospital stay was stuck downstairs, he attempted to walk up to his apartment on the 10 th floor, but was unable to make it past the second floor. He was out of breath and sweating. THESE ARE THE PEOPLE PEPCO left behind in the storm and did not make priority. While the business' and church next door had power they did not!
As far as the trees Pepco if they are contracting to these tree hackers not prunning or maintainance , the landscape is horrible and are killing the trees. We are going to see many trees coming down because of their weak state. There are trees that are more capable of handling storms believe it or not (look up trees and hurricanes etc.) they are listed. Pepco should look into underground.
RVN6768
12:05 pm on Friday, July 20, 2012
Sounds like you have an issue with the landlord not PEPCO. Why isn't the generator functioning properly? If you don't like the way the trees are pruned, get your own contractor. Spend your $$$$. Why don't your and your cohorts take the elerly into your homes...
Nearby
5:37 pm on Saturday, July 21, 2012
Given your statement that "There are trees that a more capable of handling storms," one would think that you are suggesting that PEPCO lop down all the trees along their lines and replace them with "more capable" trees, even after you gripe about the "tree hackers." We need a more coherent argument here.
Esther D
3:07 pm on Friday, July 20, 2012
This is with Pepco. The company that controls the electricity. If I find issues with the landlord or association I will surely make it know to them. Again, Pepco is what I have stated in my comment, P-E-P-C-O.
As far as the generator functioning properly... who is to say it was not? Thats irrelivent. They had no power while everyone else around them did.
Um... I do have a contractor for the trees, by no choice of mine... It is chosen for me[by Pepco]. So that is "spend your $$$$."
Me and my cohorts? Obviously, this will be my final and only comment towards you.
Nearby
5:34 pm on Saturday, July 21, 2012
Regarding Hans Riemer's statement that “There are trees and bad weather in many jurisdictions and those people have power"--yes, but in how many of those jurisdictions do the power companies have to deal with trees and limbs falling and pulling down the power lines and poles. Right before this storm there was a brouhaha on local listservs offering information as to how to fight PEPCO when they come to trim limbs in your neighborhood. Also, I've yet to see anyone that complains about PEPCO offer a data-supported analysis of their complaints. And if we have such a large problem, where have the regulators and watchdogs like the PSC been all these years? Where are their recommendations, findings, fines, etc.?