Why NO Gas Tax Hike!

Want details as to why a hike in the gas tax is, "the most unpopular idea of the year?" Read this post!

The Governor has expressed support of a 18.5 cents/gal. to 21.5cents/gal. to 27.5 cent/gal. sales  tax increase per gallon depending on whether gasoline prices are $3.50. $4 or $5 per gallon (all three with 4l.9 cents of federal and state gasoline taxes included in the price/gallon.)   The State Senate Majority Leader Garagiola, who has been the lead sponsor of gasoline tax increase legislation and who is now worried about his Democratic Primary, now says he will support an increase smaller than the Governor suggests.  
 Maryland's transportation appropriations for operating purposes declined from $3.64 billion in FY 2006 to $3.47 billion in FY 2012 while Maryland's health and mental hygiene appropriations for operating purposes jumped more than 50% from $6.33 billion to $9.73 billion during the same period.  Human Resources appropriations leaped more than 61% from $1.62 billion to $$2.61 billion.  Primary and secondary education appropriations escalated 35% from $5.11 billion to $6.90 billion.  Appropriations for the entire operating budget increased 32.4% from $25.79 billion to $34.145 billion.
So obviously transportation wasn't a priority or transportation funds were raided for other purposes.  Both are true.  Close to $1 billion was removed from transportation to the general fund during this time.
 Pennsylvania had an operating budget of $27.l billion in FY 2012, or about $ 7 billion less than Maryland while Maryland with 5.7 million people had a population less than half of Pennsylvania's 12.6 million people.  Maryland has about 5,000 more full-time employees than Pennsylvania.  Why can't we use some of the money Maryland is overspending in other areas for transportation?
 At  about $3.70 cents/gal., gasoline prices are already higher than they have ever been at this time of year.  Almost everyone is predicting that gasoline, without this huge proposed sales tax increase will this year top the all-time high average price of $4.11 in July, 2008.
 Just this past year the budget included a large increase in the state alcohol tax that was supposed to go to the handicapped, but did not.  It included new infusions of slots money.  The budget of local jurisdictions included speed camera revenues from local government cameras on state roads. But the local governments say the cameras were not put up for the revenue. Why can't the aforementioned  alcohol, slots and speed camera funds go to state transportation?  When the Governor and Garagiola  raised sales tax 20%, corporate tax 18% and top income tax bracket 52.6% from 2007-2008, why didn't we use that money for transportation?
Both the gasoline and sales tax are highly regressive, meaning that the lower incomes use a far higher percentage of their income for transportation than higher incomes.  If sales taxes are put on gasoline, the lower incomes will find it more financially challenging to get to their jobs while polls show that adding jobs is a high priority. 
Now about half of the state's transportation budget goes to mass transit. A sales gasoline tax on the 93% of workers who use the roads to get to work and on the 100% of Maryland freight that moves by road instead of mass transit to pay for the Red Line in Baltimore and the Purple Line inside the Beltway would further exacerbate the inequity of using road travelers as an ATM to pay for mass transit.  This money is not going to extending the Red Line to Montgomery Village and Germantown, which I favor.
A fairer solution is to give a higher priority to transportation within the existing budget without using what amounts to political neglect as an excuse to to raise an unfair tax.   Making Maryland's sales gasoline tax plus gasoline tax more than twice that of the gas tax in Virginia will surely drive Maryland jobs to Virginia.
Robin Ficker
The writer is a candidate for the Republican nomination of the 6th Congressional District of Maryland

This post is contributed by a community member. The views expressed in this blog are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of Patch Media Corporation. Everyone is welcome to submit a post to Patch. If you'd like to post a blog, go here to get started.

Daniel Grossberg February 29, 2012 at 01:45 PM
Interesting that Mike Miller said $0.15/gallon was too much tax to add on to gasoline. Using the number 6% must be a little less intimidating. The breakeven of course is when gas only costs $2.50/gallon. (My 5th grader figured that out by the way.) Garagiola and O'Malley must think we're idiots!
Johnny Lucid February 29, 2012 at 01:59 PM
Bravo! Some may call you a gadfly, Mr. Ficker, but you're the only one in Montgomery County who actually speaks of the facts rather than the tired, hoary old "progressive" shibboleths of our current ruling class. (County Council, County Exec, Board of Ed)
Mark Parker February 29, 2012 at 02:09 PM
<<the tired, hoary old "progressive" shibboleths of our current ruling class.>> That's classic!
Jeff Hawkins February 29, 2012 at 02:18 PM
Great comment! I had to look up the word "shibboleth", never heard that one before. Learn something everyday!


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »